I currently have a JB in that slot but something about it is just not doing it for me. Idk if it's because I have a regular spaced pup when it should be a trembucker (high e is outside of the pole pieces) or if that even matters.

Guitar is mahogany neck and chambered mahogany body for anyone who doesn't know.

Im typically playing stuff on the heavy-ish side of punk and on towards metal through a Mesa single rectifier.