I've got a Danelectro Cool Cat (9v version) that I like alright, but I'm not crazy about (especially the crappy switch). It does the job for me for now, so this isn't a priority, but I'd like to start looking for something with a bit better sound. I've had two Boss TR-2's that I hated. I've always kinda had my eye on the MXR one, but have never had a chance to try it.
I use tremolo mostly with some overdrive, I'm not a huge fan of the machine-gun type hard stutter, I prefer a softer sound. I tend to use it more on country type stuff. This is kinda what I'm going for:
When I do get around to buying a new one, I'd like to keep it around $200 or less new.