Oasis tops Beatles in UK best-album poll

[Budweiser]

Great! This is all Oasis needs! Let's pour more fuel on their already gigantic ego's.

Here's the link that list's UK's top ten albums of all time. Discuss?

http://edition.cnn.com/2006/SHOWBIZ/....ap/index.html

[Skarekrough]

Meh....it's a great album. Both that one and "Morning Glory" are fantastic releases.

I tend to think that the egos are a little less now that they've released a few albums that didn't do quite as well as the previous ones did.

[PUCKBOY99]

YEeaaahhhh........





Get back to me in 40 years & let's see if anyone knows who Oasis was.



Or cares :fing25:

[gripweed]

Oasis are not fit to shine the Beatles shoes (even the dead Beatles).

[Skarekrough]

Oasis are not fit to shine the Beatles shoes (even the dead Beatles).

Funny thing about stuffing an artist down a younger generations throats....they tend to resist.

How I long for a Beatles reunion....

[Brow]

How I long for a Beatles reunion....

All it'd take is 2 bullets

On a serious note though, Oasis did/do have some good songs, aswell as some crap. It's the same with The Beatles.

I also prefer Radioheads earlier albums (Pablo Honey, The Bends etc) to later 1's like OK Computer.

Everyone has their own versions of these lists, so it's always a point to argue over

[MikeS]

I've always failed to see what was/is so great about Oasis. They are just another UK band to me... one that isn't too particularly noteworthy.

[y2stevo]

I've always failed to see what was/is so great about Oasis. They are just another UK band to me... one that isn't too particularly noteworthy.

yup

[Voxman]

i love oasis,but something is wrong with that list!

[stevie_bees]

Lists like this suck.

[LesStrat]

So does this mean that

"Oasis is bigger than Lennon!"

[JacksonMIA]

I'll bet Jimbo figured out a way to rig the voting!

[Gearjoneser]

I wonder if that was the same CD I chucked out the window after 6 songs.

I don't hate Oasis, but to compare them to the Beatles is like comparing Noel Gallagher to George Harrison and John Lennon, and comparing Liam Gallagher to Paul McCartney. It's laughable.

[Forbes]

I much prefere Oasis to The Beatles, it doesn't get much more ove-rated than the beatles in my honest opinion. Definately Maybe is a great album, shame oasis never got near that again.

[flank]

I much prefere Oasis to The Beatles, it doesn't get much more ove-rated than the beatles in my honest opinion. Definately Maybe is a great album, shame oasis never got near that again.

in what way do you think the beatles are over-rated?

[Forbes]

in what way do you think the beatles are over-rated?

I meant the beatles are over-rated in my opinion, in the way that a huge amount of people think they are the greatest band ever, and from what i've heard i certainly wouldn't put them in that catagory at all, catchy pop-song writers maybe, but i certainly wouldn't put them in the same league as a band like The Clash or Radiohead on intelligence and generally great music. Just my opinion.

[flank]

I meant the beatles are over-rated in my opinion, in the way that a huge amount of people think they are the greatest band ever, and from what i've heard i certainly wouldn't put them in that catagory at all, catchy pop-song writers maybe, but i certainly wouldn't put them in the same league as a band like The Clash or Radiohead on intelligence and generally great music. Just my opinion.

Ok. What have you heard from the beatles, out of curiosity?

[Forbes]

All of SG Pepper, and a fair few songs from just generaly being aroiund mates/parents etc. I'm not saying they are the worst band in the world, just purely that i can't see what all the fuss is/was about.

[flank]

All of SG Pepper, and a fair few songs from just generaly being aroiund mates/parents etc. I'm not saying they are the worst band in the world, just purely that i can't see what all the fuss is/was about.

Its all good bro. You should check out Revolver, Rubber Soul, and Abbey Road. You may change your mind a little bit.

[PUCKBOY99]

Its all good bro. You should check out Revolver, Rubber Soul, and Abbey Road. You may change your mind a little bit.

or Let It Be, my personal favorite